Is Airline Premium Economy Really Worth It?

Flying these days often feels like an endurance test. You're crammed into narrow seats, vying for space in overhead bins and navigating through crowded terminals. It's no wonder that the allure of Premium Economy -- promising more space and a touch of luxury -- seems so appealing. But is it really worth the extra cash? Let's break it down.

The space factor

As coach travel gets more cramped, airlines have added Premium Economy sections that promise more space and comfort -- often at a substantially higher price. The seats are typically wider, with more pitch (the distance between rows), and they recline more, giving you a better chance at napping without waking up with a crick in your neck. However, the amount of space you actually get can vary significantly by airline. For instance, Japan Airlines offers about eight inches more legroom in Premium Economy compared to Economy, while most other carriers provide just five or six inches more.

The seats in Premium Economy are often wider than those in coach, and many include footrests. Despite these enhancements, not all seats are equally comfortable. Some airlines use a "fixed shell" design, where the seat slides forward rather than reclining, which can be less comfortable for some passengers.

Enhanced dining

Let's talk about the food. In Economy, meals are often basic and sometimes unappetizing. In Premium Economy, the dining experience gets an upgrade. For example, meals are usually served on real china on Emirates, with metal cutlery instead of plastic. The menu can be more varied, and you often get a choice between a couple of main courses.

While it's not exactly five-star dining, it's definitely a step up. The drinks selection is broader, too, often including complimentary wine and spirits. If you're a foodie or simply enjoy a better meal experience, this perk might tip the scales in favor of Premium Economy.

However, the quality of the provided extras can vary greatly. For instance, Virgin Atlantic offers priority check-in, cushy seats, and plenty of good-quality food, whereas Norwegian Air may offer less to its Premium Economy customers than other airlines provide in coach.

Amenities and extras

Premium Economy also comes with a host of little extras designed to make your journey more pleasant. Think amenity kits with eye masks, earplugs, and even mini toiletries. Blankets and pillows are usually of higher quality, making it easier to get some shut-eye.

You'll often find dedicated check-in counters and priority boarding, which can save you a significant amount of time and stress. Some airlines also include lounge access, giving you a quiet space to relax before your flight. These perks might seem minor, but they can collectively make a big difference in your overall travel experience.

Cost comparison

Of course, the real question is whether the benefits justify the cost. Premium Economy tickets can be around 50% more expensive than standard Economy tickets. For a long-haul flight, this can mean a difference of several hundred dollars.

Before you decide, consider how much the extra comfort and perks are worth to you personally. If you're traveling for a special occasion or have a particularly long flight, the investment might be worthwhile. On the other hand, if you're a budget-conscious traveler or the flight is relatively short, sticking with Economy might be the more sensible choice.

For example, the fare for a Premium Economy ticket on Virgin Atlantic from Los Angeles to London might be $1,999, while British Airways charges $3,029. The lowest Economy fares for the same route are $808 for Virgin Atlantic and $1,468 for British Airways. This means the price you pay for Premium Economy is substantially more for British Airways than for Virgin Atlantic.

Is Premium Economy worth it?

The answer largely depends on your personal preferences and travel needs. If you value comfort, better food, and a few extra luxuries, and you're willing to pay for them, then Premium Economy can significantly enhance your flying experience. It's not quite the opulence of Business Class, but it's a noticeable step up from Economy.

For frequent travelers, the benefits might justify the cost, especially if it means arriving at your destination feeling more rested and less stressed. For occasional flyers, the decision might come down to budget constraints and how much you're willing to spend on a bit of extra comfort.

No matter your flying preferences, you can save on airfare with travel rewards. If you're a frequent flyer, explore The Ascent's list of the best travel credit cards to find one that can help you cut costs.